The Dustin Penner offer sheet revisited
Written by Jay   
Saturday, 09 January 2010 00:54

dustin_penner_oilers

Dustin Penner - The Flying Fridge

Today, I started thinking about the upcoming 2010 NHL Entry Draft.  While in the midst of thinking about some of the big names in the 2010 draft class like Taylor Hall or Ryan Seguin, it occurred to me to take a look back at the 2008 NHL Entry Draft.  Specifically, I thought that it would be interesting to have a look back at the now infamous offer sheet deal that Kevin Lowe tendered for the services of one Dustin Penner.

The offer sheet deal for Dustin Penner was contentious at the time.  It sparked a lasting feud between Brian Burke and Kevin Lowe.  At the time, the $21.25 million dollar deal over five years seemed pretty generous.  Now, despite Penner's recent cold-streak, many would herald this as one of the few prescient moves made by the former Oilers GM. What happened to the three draft picks that Lowe gave up in the deal?  Let's take a look...

brian_burke

Brian Burke, former Anaheim Ducks General Manager

The feud between Brian Burke and Kevin Lowe started with some harsh words from Burke.  At the time, Burke was quoted as saying, "I have no intention of speaking to [Lowe] anytime soon,"  He later accused Kevin Lowe of being "gutless" and accused Lowe of running the Oilers "into the sewer."  This latter point might resonate with Oilers fans today as the Keving Lowe legacy does include the signing of too many spent forces for too many years. Burke then continued with accusing Lowe of throwing a "grenade" at the other 29 teams in the league with this deal.  Burke told the LA Times, "You go right now from entry-level to what used to be the third contract, thanks to two offer sheets from Kevin Lowe."

kevin_lowe5

Kevin Lowe, Oilers president of hockey operations

On the other side of this conflict over Dustin Penner, was former Oilers general manager, Kevin Lowe who tendered the offer sheet.  Lowe responded to Brian Burke's attack while interviewed by Bob Stauffer on the Team 1260 radio station.  His response included calling Brian Burke a "moron" and a "media junkie."  The NHL warned both then feuding general managers that they would have to end their public feud or face significant fines.

deal_or_no_deal

The Deal...

Again the specific terms of the offer sheet deal included a 5-year $21.25 million dollar contract along with the Oilers top-three draft picks for the 2008 NHL Entry draft.  Specifically, this included a first round, 12th overall pick in Tyler Myers, a second round, 43rd overall pick in Justin Schultz, along with a 3rd round, 73 overall pick in Kirill Petrov.  Well, to be more accurate, it's impossible to predict who the Oilers would have selected with those picks, nevertheless those are the players that Oilers draft picks were used to select.

tyler_myers_sabres

Tyler Myers, Drafted 1st round, 12th overall, 2008, by the Buffalo Sabres

Tyler Myers was drafted by the Buffalo Sabres from Edmonton via Anaheim via Los Angeles 12 overall in the 2008 NHL Entry Draft.  Basically, he represents the draft pick that the Oilers could have had if they wouldn't have made the offer sheet deal for Dustin Penner.  He's listed as 6'8, 222, and this is his first season playing in the NHL.  In 43 games played so far this season, Tyler has 6 goals and 20 assists for a combined 26 points.  His plus/minus rating is an impressive +9.  He's a player with a great pedigree including gold at the under 18 and under 20 world junior championships for Team Canada among several other accolades.

What's more is that he has a great value contract at $1.3 million dollars over this along with the next two seasons.  He's only 19-years old too.  Hockey's Future had the following to say about him prior to being drafted:

Myers has premier size and excellent potential as an offensive defenseman.  At this early stage in his development, he is already a great skater, but needs to become a more reliable passer and point man.

justin_schultz

Justin Schultz - Drafted 43rd overall, 2008,  by the Anaheim Ducks

Justin Schultz was drafted 43rd overall at the 2008 NHL Entry Draft by the Anaheim Ducks.  He's a defenseman listed at 6'1 and 171 pounds who's also just 19 years old.  During the 2008-9 season, Justin played in the BCHL putting up 50 points in 49 games.  This season, he's put up nine points in 20 games playing in the NCAA for the University of Wisconsin.  Hockey's Future provided the following talent analysis for him:

Schultz has really good hockey sense, is very good at moving the puck, and has a special knack for creating offense from the back end.  Obviously, the big knock on Schultz at 6'1, 163 is his size.  He will have to get stronger and prove himself capable of handling bigger opponents before he is ready to play pro hockey.

kirill_petrov

Kirill Petrov - Drafted 73rd overall, 2008, by the New York Islanders

Kirill Petrov was drafted 73rd overall in the 3rd round of the NHL's 2008 Entry draft by the New York Islanders from Edmonton via Anaheim.  Kirill is a big winger listed at 6'3" and 209 lbs who's currently playing in the KHL.  Like Myers, he has an impressive pedigree with gold and silver medals at the under 18 world junior championships for Team Russia.  Additionally, he was named the best forward at the U18 WJC for 2007-8.

This season, Kirill has 0 points in 8 games played in the KHL along with 10 points in six games at the U20 WJC.  There's been some confusion as to whether or not his KHL team will release him to the New York Islanders.  Again from Hockey's Future, they provided the following analysis on Kirill:

Petrov has size, speed and skill. Standing at 6’3 and almost 200 pounds, the young forward is hard to knock off the puck and can deliver an impressive physical presence, if properly motivated...

Overall, Petrov is an impressive and tempting package of physical presence, skating ability and soft hands, but who needs to further improve his defensive play and his decision making.



Digg! Reddit! Facebook! Technorati! StumbleUpon! BallHype: hype it up!
Comments (4)Add Comment
MendozaLine
...
written by MendozaLine, January 09, 2010
I would do this deal again without hesitation. Of course, hindsight is 20/20. Tyler Myers looks like he's quite a force though. It sounds like Justin Schultz would have a long road to the NHL, but Kirill Petrov might get some at bats with the Islanders organization. That is if they can figure out what's actually going on with his KHL contract/team.
0
...
written by Jay-, January 09, 2010
I was just looking at the Behind the Net site today and noticed the new updated GVT (Goals vs. Threshold) metric. Tyler Myers has a GVT of 7.1 which is very impressive given his age and contract.
HockeyNoob
...
written by Jay, January 09, 2010
Since I've been looking at GVT today, I might as well point out that Dustin Penner has a GVT of 8.9 which is the highest rating on the Oilers, not surprisingly.
MendozaLine
...
written by MendozaLine, January 14, 2010
Watch, his GVT will drop by the end of the season.

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

Follow Us

facebook_64

About Bloguin

Bloguin is the revolutionary blog network specifically focused on helping bloggers get the most out of their websites. We're currently working on building a large network of online communities and hope to expand our blogging coverage to include a wide range of topics.

Advertisers

The Bloguin Network allows advertisers to promote their products and services to our ever-growing number of visitors. We offer both site-specific ad placements as well as the ability to run a network-wide campaign. If you're interested in working with Bloguin to meet your advertising needs, please contact us.

Bloggers Wanted

The Bloguin Network is always looking to expand. We're specifically looking for blogs in the sports, entertainment, and video games field, but are open to adding any type of quality site. If you're a blogger and interested in joining our network, please fill out our application form.

The Bloguin Login

The Bloguin Login gives you full access to everything our network has to offer. Your name and password will work for each and every one of our sites. Signing up is simple, and will allow you to post in all our forums, create member blogs, and access other cool features! What are you waiting for? Create an Account!